Daily Hot Topic
Topic : Gender Identity and Athletic Fairness
GS-2 or 4 Mains : IR and Ethics
Context:
- Algerian boxer Imane Khelif faced accusations of unfair advantage due to gender identity.
- Khelif and Lin Yu-ting were banned from IBA World Championship based on “gender eligibility” test.
Gender Identity:
- An individual’s deeply felt sense of gender, may or may not align with assigned sex at birth.
- Transcends binary male/female framework.
Ancient Wisdom and Modern Challenges:
- Hindu tradition recognizes 11 genders.
- UN advocates for rights of transgender individuals.
Key Terms:
- Biological Man: Traditionally assigned male at birth based on physical characteristics.
- CJI emphasized concept of man/woman isn’t solely based on genitals.
- Transgender Woman: Gender identity doesn’t align with assigned sex at birth.
- Example: Assigned male at birth but identifies as a woman.
Larger Debate:
- Gender eligibility in women’s sports is contentious.
- Sports segregated based on sex due to average physiological advantages of men.
- Participation of trans women and women with ‘masculine’ characteristics sparks debate.
Perspectives:
- Inclusion vs. Fairness: Debate on including transgender athletes in women’s sports.
- Physiological Differences: Sports scientist Ross Tucker points to puberty-based advantages (muscle mass, aerobic capacity, bone density).
- Safety and Inclusion: Balancing transgender inclusion, fairness, and safety.
- Human Rights Consideration: Dr. Seema Patel emphasizes factors beyond physiology, including human rights, dignity, and respect for gender identity.
Conclusion:
- Ongoing conversation on transgender inclusion in sports.
- Balancing fairness, safety, and inclusivity is challenging.
हिन्दी