The Hindu Newspaper Analysis
Editorial Topic : India Needs a National Security Strategy
GS-3 Mains Exam
Revision Notes
Context:
- Need for Coherence: India needs a comprehensive strategy to unite diverse aspects like defense and finance.
- Quiet Execution: This exercise should be conducted discreetly due to potential sensitivities.
Introduction:
- Growing Demand: The need for a national security strategy is increasingly felt due to regional instability and economic challenges.
- Economic Foundation: The economy is crucial for national security as it influences resource allocation and international relations.
Interpreting the Term:
- Multiple Connotations: “National security” has various meanings for different states.
- US Example: For the US, national security is centered around values and national interests.
- Importance of Union: The US NSS emphasizes maintaining its leadership role through economic power.
Power Projection in National Security Strategies:
- Extremal Objectives: Some countries aim to intimidate rivals through their security strategies.
- Internal Objectives: Projecting strength domestically can be a political tool.
- Case Studies: The UK and France have used their national security strategies for different purposes.
National Security Strategy in India:
- Unified Approach: An NSS can integrate various aspects like defense, finance, and climate change.
- Need for Secrecy: The exercise should be conducted in secrecy to protect sensitive information.
Multi-Alignment:
- Disconnect in Speeches: Budget speeches often lack references to defense and external threats.
- Economic Strength: A strong economy is essential for maintaining sovereignty.
- Shift from Non-Alignment: India has adopted a multi-alignment approach to build relationships with various countries.
Challenges of Public Communication:
- Resource Allocation: Prioritizing threats and allocating resources is a complex task.
- Defense Capability: India faces challenges in areas like submarine and shipbuilding capabilities.
- Transparency vs. Secrecy: A public strategy might reveal weaknesses, while a secret one can be more effective.
Central Message for the Voting Public:
- Assertiveness: The public expects a strong and assertive stance on national security.
- Past Achievements: India’s past actions in defending other countries can be highlighted.
- Balancing Act: India’s approach to international relations, such as its stance on Russia-Ukraine and Gaza, requires careful messaging.
Way Forward:
- Economic Focus: A national security strategy should prioritize economic factors.
- Integrated Approach: Various annual reports and surveys should be integrated into a cohesive strategy.
- Confidentiality: The exercise should be kept confidential to avoid revealing sensitive information.
The Hindu Newspaper Analysis
Editorial Topic : New Threat to Air Passenger Safety
GS-3 Mains Exam
Revision Notes
Context:
- Electronic Devices as Threats: Recent incidents in West Asia involving exploding pagers and walkie-talkies raise concerns about the safety of air travel.
- Israeli Tactics: Israel’s actions, supported by the US and the West, pose potential risks to aviation.
Introduction:
- 9/11 Aftermath: The 9/11 attacks led to stricter security measures worldwide.
- Israeli-Designed Threat: The recent incidents in West Asia highlight new security risks.
- India’s Vulnerable Security System: India’s flawed security system makes it particularly vulnerable to such threats.
The VVIP Loophole in India:
- Security Checks: The introduction of security checks followed hijacking incidents in the 1970s and 1980s.
- VIP Exemptions: India has a unique system where certain individuals are exempt from security checks.
- Criminalised Politics: These exemptions are often granted to individuals with questionable backgrounds.
- Pegasus Spyware: India’s security system is further compromised by the use of spyware.
Basic Air Safety Protocols:
- Mobile Phone Restrictions: Passengers are required to put their phones in flight mode during flights.
- Non-Compliance: Many passengers in India do not follow this rule.
- Safety Risks: Ignoring this rule can lead to interference with aircraft systems and potential accidents.
- Shielding Technology: Airlines have implemented shielding technology to mitigate the risks of cellphone interference.
The Issue of Decompression:
- Potential Global Threat: The recent incidents in West Asia pose a significant threat to air safety.
- Small Device Explosions: Explosions in small electronic devices can cause damage and potential decompression.
- Cabin Fire and Oxygen Risk: A combination of cabin fire and oxygen deployment creates a dangerous situation.
- Need for Rethinking Safety: The incidents highlight the need for stricter security measures and revised safety protocols.
Way Forward:
- Enhanced Security: Governments and airlines need to implement stricter security measures.
- Device Restrictions: Banning certain devices and restricting Wi-Fi onboard can mitigate risks.
- VVIP Loophole Closure: India should eliminate VVIP exemptions to ensure consistent security checks.
- Proactive Measures: India must take proactive steps to protect its aviation sector from evolving threats.
हिन्दी